2024. Maximize the Confusion of an Exam
Problem Description
The problem presents a scenario where a teacher is attempting to create a true/false test that is deliberately designed to be confusing for the students. The confusion is maximized by having the longest possible sequence of consecutive questions with the same answer, either true ('T') or false ('F').
The answerKey string is given, representing the correct answers for each question, where each character is either 'T' for true or 'F' for false. Additionally, you are given an integer k which indicates the maximum number of times the teacher can change any answer in the answerKey from 'T' to 'F' or vice versa.
The objective is to find the maximum length of a subsequence of consecutive characters in the answerKey that can be the same character after performing at most k modifications.
Intuition
The intuition behind the solution relies on using a sliding window approach. The sliding window is a technique that can efficiently find a subarray or substring matching a certain condition within a larger array or string. In the context of this problem, the sliding window represents the sequence of consecutive answers that can be made the same (all 'T's or all 'F's) with up to k changes.
The main idea is to maintain two pointers, l and r, which respectively represent the left and right ends of the sliding window. These pointers move along the answerKey, expanding to the right (r increases) as long as there are characters not matching the desired one and the number of allowed changes k has not been exceeded. If the count of non-matching characters within the window exceeds k, the window is contracted by moving the left pointer (l) forward.
By performing this process twice - once to maximize the number of 'T's and once for 'F's - and taking the maximum of these two values, the solution finds the longest sequence of consecutive identical answers that can be obtained through at most k modifications.
The function get(c, k) handles this sliding window process by taking a character c ('T' or 'F') and the number of allowed changes k. It keeps track of the window by incrementing pointers and modifying the allowed changes k accordingly. The length of the longest valid window found while scanning with either character is then returned.
Finally, the maxConsecutiveAnswers function simply returns the maximum length found between the two separate iterations of the get function with 'T' and 'F' as the target characters.
Learn more about Binary Search, Prefix Sum and Sliding Window patterns.
Which data structure is used to implement recursion?
Solution Approach
The solution uses a sliding window algorithm to determine the maximum number of consecutive 'T's or 'F's that can be obtained in the answerKey, given that we can change up to k answers. The definition of the function get(c, k) inside the Solution class plays a crucial role in implementing this algorithm.
The variables l and r are pointers used to denote the left and right bounds of the sliding window, initially set to -1 since the window starts outside the bounds of the answerKey string. The while loop inside get(c, k) drives the expansion of the window to the right.
For every iteration, r is incremented to include the next character in the window. If this character does not match the target character c, k is decremented, which reflects that we use one operation to change this character to c.
If at any point the number of operations used (k) becomes negative, this means the current window size cannot be achieved as it would require more than k operations to make all characters the same as c. To rectify this, the left bound of the window (l) is moved to the right (l += 1), effectively shrinking the window from the left side. If the character at the new left bound (answerKey[l]) was a mismatch and we previously used an operation to adjust it, k is incremented since that operation is no longer needed for the new smaller window.
After expanding the window as much as possible without exceeding the maximum allowed modifications (k), the function calculates the window's size (r - l) and returns this value to the caller.
The solution approach calls get(c, k) twice, once with c = 'T' and once with c = 'F', to compute the maximum length of consecutive answers that can be obtained for both 'T' and 'F', respectively. The maximum of these two values is returned by the maxConsecutiveAnswers as the final answer to the problem.
Essentially, the algorithm leverages the sliding window technique to iterate over answerKey while keeping the modifications within the limit imposed by k, and dynamically adjusting window bounds to maximize the size of the window which represents a sequence of identical characters.
By returning the maximum between one pass with 'T' as the target character and one pass with 'F', the algorithm ensures that it considers both scenariosโmaximizing consecutive 'T's and 'F'sโultimately returning the best possible result.
This solution is efficient as both pointers (left and right) move across the answerKey in one direction only, keeping the time complexity linear, O(n), where n is the length of the answerKey.
What is the best way of checking if an element exists in a sorted array once in terms of time complexity? Select the best that applies.
Example Walkthrough
Let's consider a small example to illustrate the solution approach.
Suppose we have:
answerKey = "TFFTFF" and k = 1.
The aim is to find the maximum length of consecutive answers after changing at most one answer ('T' to 'F' or vice versa).
Step-by-Step Process to Find Maximum Consecutive 'T's
Here, we'll go through the process using get('T', k):
- Initialize pointers
landrto-1so that our sliding window is initially empty. - Start scanning the
answerKeyfrom left to right. - The
rpointer moves right one step. Whenr = 0, the character is 'T', which matches our target, so we don't need to use a change. - Move
rto1, the character is 'F', which is not our target, so we decrementkby 1 (nowk = 0because we need one change to make it a 'T'). - We can't use more changes (since
k = 0); continue to moverto the right. - At
r = 2, we have another 'T', no changes needed. - At
r = 3, we have 'F'. Since we can't change it (kis already 0), we need to movelup to release a change. Movelto0and sinceanswerKey[l]was a 'T', nokincrement. - Now we can move
rforward. Atr = 3, we change 'F' to 'T'. (Nowk = -1, which is not allowed, so we must adjustlagain). - Move
lto1. Nowkbecomes0again because we've released the change atr = 1. - At
r = 4and5, we have 'F's, but since we have no changes left, we can't include these in our sequence.
The largest sequence of 'T's that we can obtain is from l + 1 to r, which is from index 2 to 3 (subsequence "TT"). Its length is 3 - 1 = 2.
Step-by-Step Process to Find Maximum Consecutive 'F's
Repeat the same method using get('F', k):
- Initialize
landrto-1. - Scan
answerKeyfrom left to right, modifying at mostkcharacters to 'F'. - The process will find that the longest sequence of 'F's, after one modification, can be from index
1to5(subsequence "FFFFF") if we change the 'T' at index2to an 'F'. - Its length is
5 - 0 = 5.
Comparing both cases:
- Maximum length for 'T's:
2 - Maximum length for 'F's:
5
Final Answer
The final answer is the maximum of these two lengths, which in this example is 5 since the sequence of 'F's is longer.
This small illustration explains how the sliding window algorithm is used to determine the longest possible sequence of consecutive 'T's or 'F's that can be achieved by making at most k modifications. By trying both cases separately and returning the maximum value obtained from them, the algorithm yields the optimal solution to the problem.
Solution Implementation
1class Solution:
2 def maxConsecutiveAnswers(self, answer_key: str, k: int) -> int:
3 # Helper function to calculate the maximum number of consecutive answers
4 # with at most k answers being flipped to the character 'char_to_flip'.
5 def get_max_consecutive(char_to_flip, k):
6 left = right = max_length = 0
7 while right < len(answer_key):
8 # Increase the count of flips if we have a character that needs to be flipped.
9 if answer_key[right] != char_to_flip:
10 k -= 1
11 # If the maximum number of flips is exceeded, move the left pointer to the right,
12 # decreasing the count of flips if necessary.
13 while k < 0:
14 if answer_key[left] != char_to_flip:
15 k += 1
16 left += 1
17 # Update the max_length if the current window is larger.
18 max_length = max(max_length, right - left + 1)
19 # Move the right pointer to the right.
20 right += 1
21 return max_length
22
23 # Find the max consecutive answers flipping Ts or Fs and return the max of both cases.
24 return max(get_max_consecutive('T', k), get_max_consecutive('F', k))
251class Solution {
2
3 public int maxConsecutiveAnswers(String answerKey, int k) {
4 // Find the max length of consecutive answers by calling the get method twice,
5 // once for character 'T' and then for 'F'
6 return Math.max(getMaxLength('T', k, answerKey), getMaxLength('F', k, answerKey));
7 }
8
9 // Helper method to get the max length of consecutive characters in answerKey
10 // after at most k characters can be flipped
11 public int getMaxLength(char targetChar, int k, String answerKey) {
12 int left = 0; // Initialize the left pointer
13 int right = 0; // Initialize the right pointer
14 int maxLen = 0; // Variable to keep track of maximum length
15
16 // Traverse through the string using the right pointer
17 while (right < answerKey.length()) {
18
19 // if the current character does not match the target,
20 // decrement k (flip the character)
21 if (answerKey.charAt(right++) != targetChar) {
22 --k;
23 }
24
25 // If we have flipped more than k characters, move left pointer
26 // until k is non-negative (backtrack on the string)
27 while (k < 0) {
28 if (answerKey.charAt(left++) != targetChar) {
29 ++k; // Reset flip counter k because we are undoing the previous flips
30 }
31 }
32
33 // Calculate the max length of the window
34 maxLen = Math.max(maxLen, right - left);
35 }
36
37 // Return the max length of consecutive characters
38 return maxLen;
39 }
40}
411class Solution {
2public:
3 // Function to find the maximum number of consecutive answers that can be made 'true' or 'false'
4 // by flipping at most k answers.
5 int maxConsecutiveAnswers(string answerKey, int k) {
6 // Calculate the maximum consecutive sequence for both 'T' and 'F' and return the larger one.
7 return max(getMaxConsecutiveByFlipping(answerKey, k, 'T'), getMaxConsecutiveByFlipping(answerKey, k, 'F'));
8 }
9
10private:
11 // Helper function to determine the maximum number of consecutive characters that match the given character `targetChar`
12 // by flipping at most `k` characters that do not match.
13 int getMaxConsecutiveByFlipping(const string& answerKey, int k, char targetChar) {
14 int left = 0; // Left pointer of the sliding window
15 int right = 0; // Right pointer of the sliding window
16 int maxConsecutive = 0; // Track the maximum count of consecutive characters found so far
17
18 // Use a sliding window to find the longest sequence that can be made of `targetChar` by flipping at most `k` chars.
19 while (right < answerKey.size()) {
20 // If the current character is not the target, decrement k (as we would need to flip it).
21 if (answerKey[right] != targetChar) --k;
22
23 // Move the right pointer to expand the window.
24 ++right;
25
26 // If k is negative, it means we have flipped more than allowed.
27 // We must move the left pointer to shrink the window until k is non-negative again.
28 while (k < 0) {
29 // If the character at the left of the window is not the target, we increment k (as we no longer need to flip this character).
30 if (answerKey[left] != targetChar) ++k;
31 // Move the left pointer to the right to shrink the window.
32 ++left;
33 }
34
35 // Update the maximum length if needed.
36 maxConsecutive = max(maxConsecutive, right - left);
37 }
38
39 // Return the length of the longest sequence after processing the complete string.
40 return maxConsecutive;
41 }
42};
431function maxConsecutiveAnswers(answerKey: string, k: number): number {
2 // Calculate the length of the answer key
3 const lengthOfAnswerKey = answerKey.length;
4
5 // Function to get the maximum count of consecutive 'T' or 'F'
6 const getMaxCount = (target: 'T' | 'F'): number => {
7 let leftIndex = 0; // initializing the left pointer
8 let changesLeft = k; // the allowed number of changes
9 for (const char of answerKey) {
10 // If the character is not the target, decrement changes left
11 if (char !== target) {
12 changesLeft--;
13 }
14 // If no changes are left, move the left pointer forward
15 if (changesLeft < 0 && answerKey[leftIndex++] !== target) {
16 changesLeft++;
17 }
18 }
19 // The length minus the left index gives the max count for the target
20 return lengthOfAnswerKey - leftIndex;
21 };
22
23 // The maximum consecutive answers will be the max value for 'T' or 'F'
24 return Math.max(getMaxCount('T'), getMaxCount('F'));
25}
26Is the following code DFS or BFS?
1void search(Node root) { 2 if (!root) return; 3 visit(root); 4 root.visited = true; 5 for (Node node in root.adjacent) { 6 if (!node.visited) { 7 search(node); 8 } 9 } 10}
Time and Space Complexity
Time Complexity
The function get uses a sliding window approach to count the maximum consecutive answers by flipping a certain number of T or F. The inner while loop runs once for each character in answerKey as both l and r iterate over the indices from start to end without stepping backwards. Thus, the complexity of the function get is linear with respect to the length of the answerKey, which is denoted as n. Since the function get is called twice (once for T and once for F), the overall time complexity of maxConsecutiveAnswers is O(n), as the two linear passes are additive, not multiplicative.
Space Complexity
The space complexity of the code is O(1). The function get uses only a fixed number of variables (l, r, and k), which doesn't depend on the size of the input answerKey. There are no data structures used that scale with the input size, and the memory usage remains constant regardless of the length of answerKey.
Learn more about how to find time and space complexity quickly using problem constraints.
Which of the following uses divide and conquer strategy?
Recommended Readings
Binary Search Speedrun For each of the Speedrun questions you will be given a binary search related problem and a corresponding multiple choice question The multiple choice questions are related to the techniques and template s introduced in the binary search section It's recommended that you have gone through at
Prefix Sum The prefix sum is an incredibly powerful and straightforward technique Its primary goal is to allow for constant time range sum queries on an array What is Prefix Sum The prefix sum of an array at index i is the sum of all numbers from index 0 to i By
https algomonster s3 us east 2 amazonaws com cover_photos stack svg Sliding Window Maximum Monotonic Stack We have an array and a sliding window defined by a start index and an end index The sliding window moves from left of the array to right There are always k elements in
Got a question?ย Ask the Teaching Assistantย anything you don't understand.
Still not clear? Ask in the Forum, ย Discordย orย Submitย the part you don't understand to our editors.